Malachi 1:1-5 - From Doubting God’s Love to Declaring God’s Love

We’re beginning a new sermon series this morning. We’ll be in the Book of Malachi for the next couple of months. You can find Malachi chapter 1 on page 953 in the Pew Bibles.

Malachi is the last book of the Old Testament, so if you can find the book of Matthew, turn left a couple of pages.

We’ll begin with verses 1-5.

One note before I read. In these verses, you will hear of a reference to Edom. The Edomites were the descendants of Esau. That will be some helpful context.

Reading of Malachi 1:1-5

Prayer

When I was in high school and college, I spent a few summers working at a Christian camp.

Well, one particular summer, one of my fellow counsellors had a very difficult camper.

This kid was, I think, only in 1st grade. And he was rambunctious. He was mean to the other campers. He struggled to follow rules. He didn’t want to participate in activities.

In those moments, his counsellor would get down on one knee to his level, and try gently instruct him. During dangerous activities, like archery, his counsellor would often have to hold his hand, to keep him safe. Of course, the other boys in his cabin would get angry at him. Their counsellor would always intervene and remind them all to speak kind words to one another.

Well, one afternoon, things escalated. The counsellor tried to calm his camper down, but the boy lost it and started screaming. Literally, the whole camp could hear it. They were in the middle of a big group activity, so his counsellor had to gently carry him away.

As this young boy was being carried away, he kept screaming over and over, “I hate you.” “I hate you.” To which his counsellor calmly responded over and over, “I love you.” “I love you.” Their back and forth slowly faded as they passed out of sight.

The camper, of course, didn’t understand that his counsellor did love him. He didn’t know what love really looked like in that situation. To this boy, it didn’t appear to be love at all.

Maybe some of you who are parents have experienced something similar.

Well, as we get to Malachi chapter 1, God’s people, likewise, were questioning God’s love. It didn’t feel like God loved them. But he did. And in response, God mercifully reminds them of his love.

Most of us here today have at one point or another cried out to God. We’ve questioned whether he was even there or if he was loving. Maybe that is what you are feeling today.

My hope and prayer that you will leave here with a renewed or new sense of God’s love for you.

Introduction

As we get into the book of Malachi, let me first mention some background things.

Malachi is one of 12 books called minor prophets. They are called “minor” not because they are less important but because they are shorter. We don’t actually know much about the prophet Malachi other than that his name means “messenger.” He was a messenger from God.

As we will find out next week, he lived in Jerusalem. And based on the themes in the book and its position in the Old Testament cannon, Malachi prophesied sometime during the middle of the 400s BC. He very likely overlapped with Ezra and Nehemiah. At that time, some of the exiles had returned from Babylon to Jerusalem, and the temple had been rebuilt.

The last thing to point out is the word “oracle” right there in verse 1. It’s used throughout the Old Testament when a prophets were given a particularly burdensome word from God. Oracle, in fact, means burden – you know, like a heavy load that an animal would carry on its back and the weariness or distress that it would bring.

When the word “oracle” is used to describe a prophetic utterance, it is conveying the weight of that prophecy. As we work our way through Malachi, we are going to see the weight of this prophecy. Over and over, God very clearly calls for repentance from grievous sin, and God warns them if they do not return to him.

However, before all of that, God begins with a reminder of his love. And that is what verses 2-5 are about.

If you turn to page 4 of your bulletin, you can see where we are headed.

· First, God’s Love Doubted. Verse 2.

· Second, God’s Love Defended, the end of verse 2 through verse 4

· And third, God’s Love Declared, 5

So, God’s love doubted, defended, and declared.

1. God’s Love Doubted

We see right there in verse 2 that the people doubted God’s love for them.

“I have loved you,” says the Lord, but you say, “how have you loved us?”

By the way, this is the pattern throughout Malachi. God quotes the people questioning him, and then he answers. It’s the organizing framework for the book.

How have you loved us, Lord? It sure doesn’t feel like you do.

This was a difficult time in Jerusalem. We don’t often think of it that way because, after all, the people were back in Jerusalem. The temple had been rebuilt. However, socially and economically, it was a very unstable time.

Yes, the Persian kings had supported the return and rebuild, but that did not mean prosperity. No, the people experienced a lot of trouble and opposition. Taxes were high. Jobs were scarce. They were in the middle of a famine. The people had to mortgage their fields and vineyards and houses just to survive. Some even forced their sons and daughter into slavery. We know those things from Nehemiah 5. All of it weighed heavily on them.

And think about their expectations. God had promised through Isaiah and Jeremiah a return from exile back to Jerusalem. The people had in their minds the glory of the former unified kingdom – you know, prosperity and peace. They pictured Solomon’s temple restored to its original beauty and splendor. I’m sure some even pictured a return of the national power that Judah and Israel had once had.

But their expectations came crashing down with the reality of their situation. They couldn’t lift their eyes to see beyond each day… because of the difficulty that each day brought. It was not peace and prosperity, it was survival mode.

And in their minds, who was at fault? God. And so, they were asking, how have you loved us, Lord? Where have you been?

Have you or are you asking that?

Lord, do you love me? It sure doesn’t feel like it. I can’t find a job or it’s hard to financially survive each day. Or I’ve lost a parent or a spouse or a sibling or a child. Or even harder at times, my relationship with my son or daughter is estranged, or I’ve endured the pain of divorce. Or my health is deteriorating more each day, Or I struggle with chronic pain or a debilitating disease. Or my loved one is. I feel all alone. Or I’ve been a victim of abuse or false accusations.

Lord, where are you? Do you really love me?

Maybe someone told you this well-known phrases once: “God has a wonderful plan for your life.” Have you heard that before? It is one of the most unhelpful statements in evangelicalism. I’m not saying that it is not partially true. Stay tuned for that.

But becoming a Christian does not mean that you will experience peace and prosperity in this life. To be sure, being a Christian does come with many blessings on earth. Blessings in relationship and community with one another in the church. Blessings of worship and prayer, and many others things. But if we expect that our days on earth will be filled with temporal success or health or relational flourishing, we will become deeply disappointed. And it may cause us to question God’s love.

I want you to note something in verse 2. Before the Lord quotes their questioning of his love, he begins by affirming that he does love them.

“I have loved you.” By the way, that word “love” is not the word “hesed.” You know, God covenant lovingkindness. Rather, that word for “love” is the word “ahab.” It is a word for love that focuses on a loving relationship. It’s God’s love for them as his people whom he chose to be his people.

In fact, the verb form indicates that God’s love for them has been accomplished and it is definitive. It’s like saying, I *did, I do, and I will * love you. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about it. God has, does, and will love his people.

What I want to say to wrap up this first point is that in those times of doubting God’s love... in those times when you are burdened by your suffering… or when you are wondering where the Lord is, God calls you to first remember that the Lord does love you.

But rather than just leave it there, the Lord goes on to defend his love. He explains the source of his love.

2. God’s Love Defended

That brings us to #2. God’s Love Defended.

In the second half of verse 2, the Lord returns their question with a question himself. He asks, “Is not Esau Jacob’s brother?” And then reminds them of his love for Jacob and his hatred for Esau. The Israelites are Jacob’s descendants.

Now, the reason that God reminds them about Jacob and Esau is because Jacob and Esau demonstrated both God’s unmerited love as well as his just anger.

Back in Genesis 25 and following, we learn about Jacob and Esau. They were both sons of Isaac. Twins, in fact. Esau was born first, so Esau was to have the privileges of being the firstborn, authority in the family, the blessing of Isaac, and a large share of the inheritance.

But if you remember, Jacob took advantage of Esau. When Esau was famished, Esau sold his birthright to Jacob for a bowl of stew. And then Jacob lied to and tricked their father into blessing him instead of Esau.

Even though Jacob did not deserve it, God chose him and chose his descendants to be his people. Esau and his descendants, on the other hand, were rejected. You see, neither deserved God’s love, yet God chose Jacob. Jacob and his descendants were the ones who received God’s promise.

But, back to Malachi, there was the problem. To the people in Jerusalem (you know, the returned exiles), it sure felt like God loved Esau’s descendants and not Jacob’s. As I mentioned earlier, the Edomites were the descendants of Esau.

In fact, in some way, they partnered with or supported Babylon in the destruction of Jerusalem a hundred years earlier. We’re not told how, but we’re told elsewhere that Edom rejoiced in Jerusalem’s destruction. The prophet Ezekiel even mentions that Edom took vengeance against Judah. So, it’s possible Esau’s descendants even participated in Babylon’s destruction of Jerusalem.

Let me make a side note here. There is some evidence that after the Babylonian exile, another nation overthrew Edom and the Edomites were forced to move. There is also evidence that at this time Edom began rebuilding just south of Judah. If that is true, it certainly explains verses 3 and 4. They were displaced by jackals, as it says, but they began to rebuild.

I’m telling you all this because in these verses, God is both affirming his love for his people… and he is letting them know that even though Edom appears to be prospering again, it will be short-lived and their destruction would be eternal.

In contrast, the suffering that God people were experiencing would be short-lived but their prosperity would be eternal. Why? Because God chose them to be his people. He loved them with an undeserved and unconditional love.

Beloved in Christ. There are or will be times in your life when it seems like the enemies of faith are overcoming you. I’m talking about sin, death, and the devil. You will have moments when you are questioning God’s love because you don’t see a path forward. Your pain, suffering, grief, loneliness, or disappointments may overwhelm you at times.

But if God has given you the gift of faith in Christ, you are one of God’s chosen descendants of Jacob – his spiritual descendant. And God loves you. Does God have a wonderful plan for your life? Yes, because all his and your enemies will be defeated and one day, you will be rejoicing for eternity in his presence.

Do you see what I am saying. This passage, for them and for us, is ultimately fulfilled in the unmerited love of God in Jesus Christ. God chose all his people to be his people, not because of any self-worthiness. No. Just like with Jacob, despite our sin, God chose us to be his people. He called us in him before the foundation of the world. And God’s judgment against Edom is the judgment that Jesus bore on the cross for his people.

What I am saying, is that in those moments of despair and doubt. Remember not only that God loves you, but remember that he has called you to be his through Christ. And one day, God will defeat once and for all the very burdens that are weighing you down.

Just a week and a half ago, I was at an event where a missionary shared about a very difficult time. He and his wife were serving in Rwanda back during the difficult civil war there. It was tragic. Neighbors turned on neighbors. In a single day, a million people were killed. In one incident, a group or Christians fled to their church building. Their pursuers broke in and slaughtered every single one of them. As you can imagine, seeing all of it overwhelmed this missionary and his wife.

But then it became more difficult. Because, soon after that, his wife went into premature labor while there. Their son was delivered but the hospital didn’t have the expertise or medical equipment to save him. He died after only 5 days of life. This missionary described the deep struggle that he and his wife went through. They questioned God’s love and goodness in all of it.

They searched for answers.

He then recounted how Job demanded God for answers. And how God answered Job back and asked, “where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?”

And then this missionary said this: “Job never got answers, but he got presence. And in that presence, he worshipped.” That really struck me. God does not promise that we will not suffer in this life. But he does promise that he loves us and will be with us… and one day he will defeat his and our enemies forever.

This missionary closed by sharing how they were drawn back to Jesus and God’s love for them in him.

3. God’s Love Declared

Which brings us to point number 3. God’s love declared.

For the exiles who had returned to Jerusalem, both their worldview and their perception of God was small.

Remember, God had promised them many things. He had promised a Messianic king. He had promised a restoration of a kingdom beyond what could be imagined. He promised to defeat their enemies. And that was part of their struggle. None of it seemed to be coming to pass. In fact, for them, it seemed to be getting worse rather than better.

They forgot God’s love and his promises, and they lost hope.

What they needed was not only a reminder that they were God’s chosen people whom he loved. They needed a reminder of his future promises. Verse 5 says “Your own eyes shall see this, and you shall say, ‘Great is the Lord beyond the border of Israel!’”

Most prophecies in the Bible have a more immediate fulfillment but also a future redemptive fulfillment. For the immediate, there is some historical record that the Edomites were soon overcome by both Greek and then Roman conquests.

But I think verse 5 is really meant to draw their attention to the future. To point them to a coming king who will be victorious, not only in Israel, but as verse 5 says, beyond its borders.

It’s like God was saying to them through Malachi, “Yes, I love you, but I also want you to lift your eyes up from your suffering to see what I will do! It will be far greater than you can imagine. Not only will the enemies of faith be destroyed, but you will see the greatness of my salvation to the world”

As you may have figured out, it was still about 450 years before Jesus’ birth. God was not saying that those particular people in Jerusalem would see the ultimate fulfillment of this verse. Perhaps they would see Edom overcome. But remember, the Lord was speaking to Israel. It is through them that that Savior would come. This is the last period in their history before Jesus came. And when he came, he would bring salvation not only to Israel, but his electing love would greatly expand beyond the border of Israel to the world.

Beloved in Christ, you and I are part of this promise. We are here today worshiping our God who has saved us because God has and is fulfilling this promise to Israel. Christ has come and His Gospel is going forth in mighty ways throughout the earth.

This is part of God’s reminder to us when we are doubting his love. Yes, we can rest in the fact that we are God’s people. We have his love in Christ. But in times of suffering and disappointment and grief and despair, we can lift our eyes up to see what God is doing all around us and around the word. It is truly amazing. And by seeing what God is doing, believing what he will do, we can and should then declare his love to the world.

As verse 5 puts it, “you shall say, ‘Great is the Lord beyond the border of Israel!’”

From doubting God’s love to declaring God’s love.

Conclusion

As we close, let me briefly say that these opening verses are the foundation to the rest of Malachi. We’re going to see over and over the sin of the people, the sin of the priests, and the Lord’s call for them to repent and return to him.

Malachi begins where they needed to begin… it begins where we need to begin. Knowing and believing in God’s saving and electing love in Christ.

So, in our doubt and discouragement and pain, may we know and believe in God’s undeserved love for us in Christ – he has chosen us in him. May we lift our eyes to see what he is doing, and may we declare the greatness of our God in all of it. Amen.